Quick Look at R&T's List
R&T's classification states that there are precisely 7 leadership categories.
…No, just 6—because one of these is not about leadership at all: the Diplomat. The Diplomat does not even want to lead, control or influence people. That surely rules them out of the classification by any reasonable definition.
Read more about «R&T's Diplomats» here.
THEE's Observation: R&T surveyed managers and professionals in roles where leadership is a requirement. That could be useful, but it does not enlighten us on leadership. For that we surely need to focus on when and how those people actually lead.
So there are just 6 R&T leadership categories.
…No, just 5—because one of these is a category of person who does not fit easily into organizations and never leads large groups. This is the Individualist. At most, such people can run a rather small project team, and usually only for a short period of time.
R&T's example ('Sharon') confirms this observation, because R&T tell us that she led a successful project team but did not it in to the wider organization and left the firm to set herself up as a consultant.
Read more about «R&T's Individualists» here.
THEE's Observation: Leadership is not the only way to achieve and make a contribution within organizations. R&T seem to have equated the «personal capacity for group achievement» with a «suitability for leadership».
So there are just 5 R&T leadership categories.
…No, just 4—because one of these is rather strange.
We might call someone a Diplomat or an Achiever—but an Alchemist? There is something not quite right with that name.
R&T seem to have created a catch-all category for remarkable, charismatic people whose capabilities are well beyond the norm.
Read more about «R&T's Alchemists» here.
THEE's Observation: Unusually capable and charismatic people are certainly found in leadership positions, but they do not comprise a single category.
So we are left with 4 plausible R&T leadership categories,
as follows:
Come with us as we look at each by take specific terms and phrases from R&T's article and search for them in THEE. After that, we will try to make sense out of the three false positives explained above.
Last Updated: 12-Jan-2012